A Rare Case of Albright’s Hereditary Osteodystrophy Presenting as Recurrent Hypocalcemic Tetany

An internist with an eagle’s eye can diagnose many hidden diseases through careful examination. One such hereditary metabolic disorder is Albright’s Hereditary Osteodystrophy (AHO). Characteristic presentations in an individual affected by AHO were short stature, obesity, mild mental retardation and brachydactyly especially of 4th and 5th digits, which are the phenotypic features of genetic mutation. Pseudohypoparathyroidism (PHP) is characterized by inability of the body to respond appropriately to parathormone, mainly characterized by hypocalcaemia, increased serum parathormone concentration, insensitivity to the biological activity of parathormone and hyperphosphatemia. AHO when seen in association with resistance to parathormone (PTH), it is called PHP. Here is a case report of 22-year-old female patient with AHO with distinctive physical characteristics who presented to us with recurrent hypocalcaemic tetany.

Keywords:Hyperphosphatemia; Hypocalcaemia; Pseudo Hypoparathyroidism; Brachydactyly; Albright Hereditary Osteodystrophy (AHO)

Albright’s hereditary osteodystrophy(AHO) is a form of osteodystrophy,[1] and is classified as the phenotype of pseudo hypoparathyroidism type 1A; this is a condition in which the body does not respond to parathyroid hormone. [2] It is characterized by a metabolic disorder that can be inherited in an autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, or X-linked dominant form. The disorder bears the name of Fuller Albright, who characterized it in 1942. [3]He was also responsible for naming it “Sebright bantam syndrome,” after the Sebright bantam chicken, which demonstrates an analogous hormone insensitivity. Much less commonly, the term pseudo hypoparathyroidism (PHP) andacrodyostosis.3Martin-Albright syndrome is used, this refers to Eric Martin. [4] It is a heterogeneous group of disorder characterized by hypocalcemia, hyperphosphatemia, increased serum concentration of parathyroid hormone, and insensitivity to the biological activity of PTH due to resistance toward parathyroid hormone. This defect is caused by gene mutation in GNAS1 gene, which results in partial or total deficiency of Gs-alpha activity and thus involves the impairing of function of the biochemical pathways responsible for the activation of parathormone receptors; therefore, it leads to resistance to PTH action.

Apart from features that are common to all forms of hypoparathyroidism, i.e., short stature that is usually evident in late childhood), obesity, mental retardation, subcutaneous ossification, brachydactyly (metacarpal and metatarsal shortening), hypogonadism, and hypothyroidism. [5] Dental defects include enamel hypoplasia and blunt root development. It is an important cause of delayed eruption of teeth. [6] There is considerable phenotypic variability of the disease in the same family and in the same generation.

A 22-year-old married housewife with a history of repeated hypocalcaemic tetany, diagnosed at 2 years, presented with two new episodes of generalized tonic–clonic seizures and tingling sensation over perioral regions and both upper and lower limbs for last 2 days. She did not have a history of vomiting, loose stool, head trauma, fever, headache, stroke, hypertension, diabetes. But her mother, who died of stroke 3 years back, had history of repeated seizure, the cause of which was not evaluated. There was no history of consanguinity of marriage among her parents. Her birth history was uneventful with no history of any perinatal asphyxia, pre term labour or low birth weight. The patient denied any thyroid or other neck surgery but her milestone of development was delayed and she had history of delayed eruption of her tooth. Her menstrual history was irregular and she had no issues in her 6 years of marital life. She also had history of recurrent tingling of her limbs and seizure for last 8 years which was managed conservatively in local hospitals with irregular intake of anti epileptics. Physical examinations revealed that she is short statured, overweight with short neck (figure 1) (height: 152 cm, weight: 62 kg, body mass index [BMI]: 26.8). Round-shaped face (figure 2), and brachydactyly were present as evidenced by knuckle knuckle dimple dimple sign (Archibald’s sign) (figure 3).

Her vital signs were as follows: blood pressure was 110/70 mm Hg; pulse rate was 74 beat per minutes; respiratory rate was 20 breaths per minutes; and body temperature was 36.3°C. Oral examination revealed multiple carious teeth with halitosis. There were hypoplastic teeth with no enamel hypoplasia. Neurological examination revealed clear consciousness, with no cranial nerve abnormalities, no tremor or no bradykinesia. In addition to some cognitive impairment, on examination she had a positive Trousseau sign (flexion of the wrist and metacarpophalangeal joints when blood pressure cuff if inflated above the systolic blood pressure) and Chvostek sign (twitching of the ipsilateral facial muscles on tapping on the face at a point just anterior to the ear and just below the zygomatic bone). Laboratory studies: CBC was normal in all cell line, s. electrolyte- sodium 139 mmol/l, potassium 4.4 mmol/l, HCO3- 28 mmol/l, s. creatinine 0.47 mg/dl (normal 0.2- 1.1 mg/dl), s. calcium 5.2 mg/dL (8.5–10.5 mg/dL), s. albumin 47.63(so corrected calcium 3.79 mg/dl), s. phosphate 6.69 mg/dL (2.6–4.5 mg/dL), s. magnesium 0.7 mmol/l (normal 0.66- 1.2 mmol/l) intact parathyroid hormone 218.6 pg/dL (11–67 pg/dL) with TSH 11.7(normal 0.35- 5.5), LH…., FSH…. and 25-hydroxyl vitamin D 31.33 ng/dL (30–65 ng/dL). MT was non conclusive, ANA was negative (5.5 U/ml). Urinary calcium revealed hypocalciuria< 2. CT of the brain revealed bilateral symmetrical calcification of both choroid plexus of posterior horn of lateral ventricles (figure 4). EEG revealed featured suggestive of secondarily generalized epilepsy. X ray of hand revealed short 4th and 5th metacarpals (figure 5). A line is drawn transgential to the distal portion of the fourth and fifth metacarpals. In normal subjects, it should not intersect the third metacarpal. This sign is positive in our patients (Archibalds sign). Genetic evaluation could not be done due to unavailability in our country. OPG revealed hypoplastic anterior teeth (figure 6).

Treatment plan included medication with 1 gram of levetiracetam, 2gms of Calcium acetate orally, 100mcg vitamin D3 daily, thyroxine 50 mcg daily was started as initial phase of treatment. Patient was recalled after three weeks wherein hematological investigations were carried out. There was a considerable increase in serum calcium level to 8.8mg%, serum phosphate recorded was 4.7mg% which was reduced compared to initial values and PTH levels were 92.5pg/dl which showed considerable reduction from the aforementioned values.

Parathormone is the principal hormone that maintains serum calcium and phosphorous levels in the body. Parathormone functions mainly includes, enhanced distal tubular resorption of calcium, promotion of bone resorption, increased synthesis of 1,25 hydroxy vitamin D, therefore, leading to enhanced intestinal calcium absorption [7,8,9,10].

PHP is a term applied to a heterogeneous group of disorders where the most common feature is theresistance to parathyroid hormone. [11] Most of the patients have hypocalcemia and hyperphosphatemiadespite elevated concentration of parathyroid hormone in plasma. This is due to the loss of the phosphaturicaction of parathyroid hormone and reduced formation of 1, 25-dihydroxy vitamin-D with resultant defective mobilization of calcium from bone and reduced GIT absorption of calcium. PHP type Ia is associated with resistance to multiple hormones in addition to parathyroid hormone and with a constellation ofphysical abnormalities collectively termed as AHO [12].

Genetic studies done to know the etiology of AHO has revealed mutation of GNAS1 gene located on 20q13-11 as the culprit gene [8].

In literature, AHO has been reported with characteristic features like short stature, round face, flat, wide and low nasal bridge, short neck, flat occiput, brachydactyly of 4th and 5th digits(usually bilateral,13due to premature skeletal development and closure of epiphysis), knuckle dimples in the clenched fists, short broad nails, osteoporosis, cataract, dementia, epileptic seizures, ankylosis of TMJ, rheumatoid arthritis of hand and foot joints, cone shaped epiphysis, thickened calvaria, basal ganglia and choroid plexus calcification and subcutaneous ossification [9,10,14,15]. Our case also coincides with these findings. Obesity and mild mental retardation are often seen in these patients because lipolyticfactors act by stimulating cAMP formation, and abnormalities in cAMP metabolism are associated with learning defect. In our case, we noticed a typical silver beaten appearance of skull.

The present case gave a familial history of AHO which is notin agreement to studies done by Monica Gomes et al., but similar to series of erratic cases reported in literature [6,9]. Cases documented previously show preponderance of AHO in female individuals, stating that AHO occurs twice frequently in females than males. In accord with female preponderance are studies done by Davies and Hughes, Fitch N et al., Sunder and Singh, and EselErtugrul et al. [14,16,17,18].

TMJ ankylosis has been reported in case reports by Ambika L &Vaishali K and Goldberg et al., but the presenting case shows no ankylosis of TMJ [9,19]. Basal ganglia and choroid plexus calcification seen in Computed Tomography (CT) has also been reported by Ambika L &Vaishali K, Wilson L & Richard and Seema Kapoor et al., and Livia et al., [8,9,10,21]. The reason for the focal accumulation of calcium in basal ganglia can be due to local factors and disturbance of calcium metabolism. Dementia, siezures and Parkinsonism are seen associated with basal ganglia calcification [14,20].

Oral manifestations in AHO patients include aplasia, thin enamel with enlarged pulp chamber, hypoplasia, hypodontia, pulp calcification, multiple carious teeth, multiple unerupted teeth, crowded anterior teeth, anterior open bite, gingival hyperplasia, gingivitis with spontaneous bleeding and pain [9,10]. In addition, there was also the presence of malocclusion impairing proper oral hygiene and favoring the accumulation of bacterial plaque and calculus.

Patients with PHP Iahave AHO phenotype resistance to G-protein-coupled hormone, attenuated response to urinary phosphate and cAMP excretion after intravenous infusion of synthetic PTH, and decreased Gs-alpha activity [22]. In some patients, this phenotype is found without biochemical evidence of PTH resistance. This has been termed as PPHP. [23] The abnormalities in various types of PHP have been depicted in the Table 1.

A variety of disorders shares certain features in common with PHP type Ia, but in general is readily distinguished from it. Therefore differential diagnosis has to be made before deciding for appropriate diagnosis. Soft tissue ossification is present in myositis ossificans but differ in location (muscle) from that in PHP Ia (subcutaneous). The pattern of metacarpal shortening differs in PHP Ia and Turner syndrome, but the latter is not associated with resistance to PTH. The main difference now remains secondary hyperparathyroidism. Alkaline phosphtase levels are usually increased manifolds in this condition with characteristic appearance of ostitis fibrosa cystica.

All patients with severe symptomatic hypocalcemia should be treated with intravenous calcium. Administration of oral calcium and alpha hydroxylated vitamin-D metabolite such as cholecalciferol remains the mainstay of treatment and with close observation periodically. The dental treatment involves themanagement of carious teeth along with planning for correction of malocclusion.

The findings of general and oral manifestation of AHO described in our report contribute to the clinical picture of AHO that is developing in the literature. AHO is a longstanding disorder, which needs careful examination and symptomatic treatment. As dentist, careful examination of physical characteristics and thorough evaluation of tooth eruption in accordance with chronological age of the patient can help in early diagnosis of patients with AHO. Multidisciplinary approach can help in accurate diagnosis and on providing prompt treatment to the patient.

Conflict of interest: None declared